top of page
Search

When Hopelessness Hits: Managing Suicidal Thoughts and Finding a Way Back

Nov 10
8 min read

There are moments in life when emotional pain becomes so overwhelming that the mind begins to tell us there is no way out. Not necessarily because we truly want life to end, but because we desperately want the way we are feeling to end. This is an important distinction.


Suicidal ideation often appears when psychological pain combines with hopelessness. A person may no longer be able to imagine their circumstances changing, cannot see themselves coping with what is happening, and begins to experience the future as simply more of the present. Thoughts such as “Nothing is going to change,” “I can't keep doing this,” “Everyone would be better without me,” or “I've ruined everything” can start to feel less like thoughts and more like facts.


But hopelessness is a psychological state. It is not a reliable prediction of the future.


When we are severely depressed, traumatised, ashamed, grieving or emotionally exhausted, our ability to imagine alternatives can become significantly narrowed. When we are emotionally regulated, we can usually hold more than one possibility in mind: This is terrible, but perhaps something can change. I made a mistake, but maybe I can repair it. This relationship ended, but another life may still be possible. I failed at something, but that doesn't make me a failure.


Hopelessness gradually removes those alternatives. It becomes one problem, one interpretation, one unbearable future, and, eventually, what can seem like only one solution. This is one of the reasons suicidal thoughts should never be faced alone.


Therapy can help widen that tunnel again. The immediate goal is not necessarily to persuade someone that life is wonderful or insist that they think positively. When someone is experiencing deep emotional pain, being told to “look on the bright side” can make them feel even more alone and misunderstood. Sometimes the therapeutic goal is much smaller and more realistic: do not make a permanent decision while your mind is in its darkest place. We can work on tomorrow later. Right now, we may simply need to get through today—or sometimes the next hour.


One of the most powerful examples of how quickly suicidal certainty can change comes from Kevin Hines, who survived a suicide attempt from the Golden Gate Bridge at the age of 19. Hines has since spent much of his life speaking about suicide prevention, mental illness and recovery. In his book Cracked, Not Broken: Surviving and Thriving After a Suicide Attempt, and in subsequent interviews, he has spoken openly about the extraordinary change that occurred immediately after he jumped: he regretted his decision and wanted to live.


What makes this part of his story so important is that nothing external had changed in those few seconds. The problems that had brought him to the bridge had not disappeared. His mental illness had not suddenly resolved. His circumstances had not magically improved. What changed was the mental state from which those circumstances were being perceived.

There is a deeper lesson in that. The person we become during the most unbearable minutes of our lives should not be given sole authority over the rest of our lives.


This is why creating time between a suicidal thought and an irreversible action matters. Suicidal thoughts can be frightening, repetitive and incredibly convincing, but thoughts are not instructions. Learning to recognise “I am having the thought that I cannot continue” as different from “I cannot continue” creates a small but potentially important psychological distance.


In therapy, we often work backwards and look at what happens before the suicidal thought arrives. There may be a trigger, followed by a particular interpretation, then an emotional response, changes in the body, withdrawal, shame, hopelessness and eventually suicidal thinking. Once we understand that sequence, there are more places where we can intervene.

For one person, recovery may require medication and treatment for depression. For another, trauma therapy may be necessary. Someone else may need help with alcohol or substance use, sleep, grief, emotional regulation, an abusive relationship, chronic shame or overwhelming anxiety. Another person may need to learn something they have never really learned before: how to experience rejection, disappointment or failure without interpreting it as evidence that they themselves are a failure.


Recovery is rarely one inspirational conversation or one dramatic breakthrough. More often, it is built through many relatively ordinary decisions—to stay, to speak, to accept help, to tolerate another difficult day, to make another appointment, to tell the truth when things are deteriorating and gradually to build a life that feels possible again.


There is understandable concern about suicidal ideation and psychological distress among younger generations. Suicide remains one of the leading causes of death among young people internationally, and high levels of sadness and hopelessness continue to be reported among adolescents. At the same time, we need to avoid reducing this to a single explanation or describing today's young people as simply more fragile than previous generations. Suicide and suicidal ideation are complex and usually involve multiple interacting factors.


Young people today are growing up in an environment that previous generations did not experience in quite the same way. They can be exposed almost continuously to social comparison, idealised bodies, apparently perfect relationships, extraordinary lifestyles and highly curated versions of other people's success. Rejection no longer has to happen privately; it can happen publicly and stay visible online. Bullying can follow a child home through a phone. There is academic pressure, uncertainty about the future, economic anxiety, family difficulties, loneliness, disrupted sleep, questions around identity and, for some, trauma, neurodevelopmental difficulties, mental illness or substance use.


Another factor deserves consideration: our relationship with failure and discomfort.


For understandable reasons, many parents want to protect their children from the painful experiences they themselves endured. We want children to feel valued. We tell them they are special, that they can achieve anything, that they should follow their dreams and that if they work hard enough, they can succeed.


There is kindness behind those messages. The problem is that life eventually introduces a much less comfortable reality.


Sometimes you work incredibly hard and still don't get what you want. Someone else gets the university place. You don't get the job. A relationship ends. Someone doesn't love you back. You lose. You make a terrible decision. You embarrass yourself. Your business fails. Your friends exclude you. Your body changes. You discover that you are average at something you desperately wanted to be exceptional at.


None of these experiences feels good, but they are part of being human.


If we remove every obstacle, disappointment and consequence from a young person's life, we may unintentionally remove opportunities to discover something extremely important: I can experience something painful and survive it.


I can fail and recover. I can be rejected and remain valuable. I can receive criticism without collapsing. Someone can dislike me, and I can tolerate it. I can make the wrong choice and make another one. I can lose something important and grieve it. I can feel embarrassed without needing to disappear. I can feel intense emotions without needing to escape them immediately.


Resilience does not develop because nothing bad happens to us. It develops partly because difficult things happen and, with appropriate support, we discover that we can move through them.


This becomes especially important when self-worth is closely tied to achievement. There is a significant psychological difference between thinking “Something I tried failed” and thinking “I am a failure.” The first describes an event. The second turns an event into an identity.


Perfectionism can make this particularly dangerous. When someone believes they must perform, achieve, look, or behave a certain way to remain worthy, mistakes can become intolerable. A setback is no longer simply disappointing; it can become evidence of personal defectiveness. Add depression, shame, social comparison or isolation, and the psychological consequences can become much more serious.


Perhaps, then, one of the things we need to teach young people is not that life should be easy, but that they can live through the times when it isn't.


That means allowing manageable frustration. Allowing consequences. Teaching emotional regulation rather than removing every uncomfortable emotion. Helping young people solve problems without immediately solving the problems for them. Normalising mistakes. Talking about our own failures. Teaching them that asking for help and tolerating difficulty can exist together.


We should not remove every stone from the road. We need to help people learn how to walk when the road becomes difficult.


Good therapy does not promise that you will never again feel depressed, frightened, rejected or hopeless. It helps you develop a different relationship with those states.


Over time, someone who has experienced suicidal ideation may begin to recognise: I've felt like this before. My thinking becomes very absolute when I'm depressed. I know my warning signs. I know what makes things worse. I know who I need to contact. I know that isolating myself is dangerous for me. I know that alcohol makes these thoughts stronger. I know I don't need to solve my entire life tonight.


This is recovery too.


Recovery is not simply the absence of suicidal thoughts. It can mean becoming increasingly able to recognise them, understand what has activated them, respond earlier and know that an unbearable emotional state can pass without having to act upon it.


It also means learning to ask for help before reaching the edge.


If suicidal thoughts begin to appear, try to reduce the size of the problem. You do not need to decide what the rest of your life will look like. You need to remain safe while your thinking is at its most compromised.


Tell someone what is actually happening. Do not reduce “I'm frightened that I may hurt myself” to “I'm having a bad day.” Contact your therapist, psychiatrist, doctor, crisis service or someone you trust. Do not isolate yourself. Create distance between yourself and anything you could use to seriously harm yourself. If necessary, ask someone to stay with you or help secure medication or other potentially dangerous means.


Alcohol and recreational drugs are particularly dangerous at these times because they can worsen depression, increase impulsivity and reduce the distance between thought and action.


If you have developed a safety plan with your therapist, use it. If you have not, consider creating one when you are stable. The best time to decide what you will do during a suicidal crisis is before the next crisis arrives.


And if you believe you may act on suicidal thoughts, have begun preparing to harm yourself, or cannot keep yourself safe, this is an emergency. Contact emergency services or go to the nearest emergency department.


Perhaps the most important message is that you do not need to feel hopeful before accepting help.


You do not have to believe that everything will be okay. You do not even have to believe that therapy will work. When you cannot hold hope yourself, somebody else can temporarily hold it for you, a therapist, psychiatrist, partner, parent, sibling, friend, doctor or crisis counsellor.


Sometimes the only commitment necessary at that moment is:

“I don't know whether things can get better, but I am willing not to make this decision today.”

 

Kevin Hines could not see the life that was ahead of him when he stood on the Golden Gate Bridge at 19. The fact that he later built a life in which he could speak publicly about survival and recovery does not minimise how real his suffering was at the time. It demonstrates something different: we cannot see future chapters from inside the darkest chapter of our lives.


Hopelessness tells us that there are no more chapters.


Recovery teaches us not to believe everything hopelessness says.


If you are experiencing suicidal thoughts, please do not manage them alone. Tell someone you trust and contact your therapist, psychiatrist, doctor or another mental-health professional. If you believe you are in immediate danger of acting on suicidal thoughts, contact emergency services in your area or go to your nearest emergency department.


In the United States, call or text 988 for the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, available 24 hours a day: 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline: https://988lifeline.org/


In the United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland, you can contact Samaritans free on 116 123, 24 hours a day: Samaritans: https://www.samaritans.org/


In Thailand, the Department of Mental Health operates the 1323 Mental Health Hotline, available 24 hours a day: Department of Mental Health: https://dmh.go.th/


If you live elsewhere, Befrienders Worldwide can help you find emotional-support and crisis services in your country: Befrienders Worldwide: https://befrienders.org/


You can also contact your nearest hospital or emergency department, primary-care doctor, community mental-health service, school or university counselling service, addiction service, or a trusted person in your personal support network.


There is no requirement to be “suicidal enough” before asking for help.

You don't have to wait until you are standing at the edge to tell someone you are struggling.

 

 
 
bottom of page